Travelling fires pose an underestimated risk to open building spaces

New research from Imperial College London has shown that travelling fires pose a risk to the structures of large open building spaces over 100m2.

With more and more large office spaces designed as open-plan, the researchers say their findings should be taken into particular consideration when designing spaces like offices and warehouses larger than 100m². 

The lesser-known ‘travelling fires’, which travel within large building compartments rather than engulfing whole rooms at once, can cause at least as much structural damage and potential  building collapse as typical fires. They are likely to be especially prevalent in large spaces with ample fuel and fewer doors and interior walls, like open-plan offices and warehouses.

Structural engineers design buildings to survive fires use guidelines like standard fire and Eurocode parametric fires. Using these guidelines, they typically focus on the fires that engulf whole rooms at once, known as flashover fires. 

This new research, published in the journal Fire Technology, shows that open spaces are also vulnerable to travelling fires - a lesser-known fire type that burns locally and moves across an entire floor over time. 

We found that buildings with open plans are in fact vulnerable to travelling fires, but this fire type is not yet weighted as heavily as flashover fires when designing buildings. Professor Guillermo Rein Department of Mechanical Engineering

Senior author of the paper Professor Guillermo Rein of Imperial’s Department of Mechanical Engineering and Hazelab said: “Previous fire experiments have found that designing against flashover fires is key for buildings with smaller spaces separated by walls and doors. However, now that structural engineers are designing large open-plan spaces more frequently, it’s important to better understand how fires behave in these spaces.

“We found that buildings with open plans are in fact vulnerable to travelling fires, but this fire type is not yet weighted as heavily as flashover fires when designing buildings. We want engineers to understand that protecting against travelling fires could be just as important as protecting against more typical ones. By considering both fire types, engineers can be confident that they are considering the worst-case scenario.” 

Travelling fires 

Some modern structures have open-plan spaces between four and 50 times larger than the largest compartment fire experiments conducted to date. Dr Egle Rackauskaite Department of Mechanical Engineering

Traditional engineering guidelines for assessing fire safety in new buildings are based on observational experiments of fire dynamics in compartments much smaller than 100m². These experiments have led to the assumption that flashover fires should be the main objective in structural design against fire. However, due to the lack of experiments in larger compartments, the potential significance of travelling fires in larger compartments is poorly understood.

To put travelling fires to the test, Imperial researchers designed the largest compartment fire experiment ever conducted, known as x-ONE. Using a disused 380m2 open-space concrete farm building in Poland, they started a fire at one end and measured its behaviour as it spread across the 35.5-metre-long compartment. Before doing so, they applied fire protection to columns to prevent structural damage and laid down a bed of fuel to feed the fires. 

Within 12 minutes, the fire had spread the length of the compartment and had increased in speed from 0.33 to 16.7 centimetres per second as the size of the fire increased. It burned out after 25 minutes. Despite the size increase, the fire did not reach flashover. 

The researchers reported that the fire dynamics observed during x-ONE differed greatly from the fire dynamics reported in small-scale compartment fires in previous studies. The findings also challenge flashover fires as the sole worst-case scenario in designing buildings.  

They say this highlights the need for further experiments in large compartments to understand open-space fire dynamics and continue improving the safe design of modern buildings.

Dr Egle Rackauskaite, who led the work while at Imperial’s Department of Mechanical Engineering and Hazelab, said: “Despite the lack of advanced studies, travelling fires have been observed in real incidents - for example, in the World Trade Centre towers after the 11 September 2001 attacks. However, these fires have rarely been studied on an experimental basis. At the same time, some modern structures have open-plan spaces between four and 50 times larger than the largest compartment fire experiments conducted to date. This highlights a key knowledge gap in fire engineering design which must be addressed with further research.” 

This research was supported by Centre d’Étudeset de Recherches de l'Industrie du Béton (CERIB, France), Ove Arup and Partners Limited (UK), the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC, UK), and Educational & Scientific Foundation of the Society of Fire Protection Engineers (SFPE, USA) in collaboration with Instytut Techniki Budowlanej (ITB, Poland), and The Main School of Fire Service (Poland) 

“Fire Experiment inside a Very Large and Open-Plan Compartment: x-ONE” by Rein et al., published 1 October 2021 Fire Technology. 

Images and video: IMPERIAL HAZELAB 2017 

See the press release of this article